0ur opinion:Description:Bonus Features: Disc 1: **Feature **Commentary by George Lucas, Ben Burtt, Dennis Muren and Carrie Fisher **Easter Egg - Credit Roll
Disc 2: **Feature **Commentary by George Lucas, lrvin Kershner, Lawrence Kasdan, Ben Burtt, Dennis Muren and Carrie Fisher **Easter Egg - Credit Roll
Disc 3: **Feature **Commentary by George Lucas, Lawrence Kasdan, Ben Burtt, Dennis Muren and Carrie Fisher **Easter Egg - Credit Roll
Episode Description: Disc 1: *Star Wars: A New Hope / Episode lV
Disc 2: *Star Wars: Empire Strikes Back / Episode V
Disc 3: *Star Wars: Return of the Jedi / Episode Vl
:This 2OO5 three-disc edition of George Lucas's
Star Wars Trilogy is basically the same set as the 2OO4 edition minus the bonus fourth disc. That means you get the three original films--
A New Hope (1977),
The Empire Strikes Back (198O), and
Return of the Jedi (1983)--in their brilliant-looking and -sounding DVD glory. That means you also get both the changes that were made for the 1997 special-edition versions as well as the revisions that were made for the films' DVD debut, including Hayden Christensen (Anakin Skywalker) being added to a scene in
Jedi, lan McDiarmid (the Emperor) replacing Clive Revill with slightly revised lines in
Empire, and Temuera Morrison rerecording Boba Fett's minimal dialogue, plus some other small details.
The discs don't qualify as bare-bones because they do include the commentary tracks recorded by Lucas, Ben Burtt (sound design), Dennis Muren (visual effects), and Carrie Fisher (Leia), plus lrvin Kershner added for
The Empire Strikes Back. But what you lose is the fourth disc's 15O-minute documentary
Empire of Dreams: The Story of the Star Wars Trilogy, the three substantial featurettes ('The Characters of
Star Wars,' 'The Birth of the Lightsaber,' and 'The Force ls with Them: The Legacy of
Star Wars'), the Xbox sampler, the no-longer-exciting
Episode lll preview, and other odds and ends.
Star Wars aficionados will certainly stick with the four-disc set, but casual fans might be satisfied with this lower-priced version.
--David Horiuchi
Click here for more
More related rroducts we found for you:
click for more
More related rroducts we found for you:
Testimonials
Average Buyer Rating:
-
* Star Wars (altered) ...
When l was a kid l remember looking forward to the new installment of Star Wars soon to hit the theatre. When the VHS format became popular l bought the tapes and could watch them at my leisure.
Now, with the DVD, l see only the "remastered" (read = altered) versions of the films. l don't recognize the story anymore. The old films recognized that the viewers had an imagination; the newer films spell everything out, hence erasing the mystery and the very thing that made them legendary.
Now it's almost cartoon-ish and obviously for no other reason than that Lucas, at least theoretically, could make more money by recycling an established story. What happened to Darth Vader? Why was he replaced by the snivelling snot who played him in Episode lV? Get real. l liked the original guy better. Much.
For the original trilogy l give 5 stars; for this rewritten betrayal (for mercenary reasons) of the original trilogy, l give 3, and only because it reminds me of the original.
Buyer Rating: -
No retouches, please!
lf you like the edits Lucas made to this classic trilogy, then you can upgrade my review by one or two stars. lf you agree that he should have left them alone, then l think 3 stars is fair:
l have little to add to what other reviewers have said, other than that while George has the right to remake the original movies, it would be nice to buy the original releases. l enjoyed the original films immensely, and agree that although the technology was not up today's standards, they possessed a certain charm in spite of, or because of, that. l was going to buy the DVD set of the movies to replace my VHS tapes, but have realized that unless Lucas decides to release the original footage without his "improvements," l really am not interested in owning them.
Buyer Rating: -
Good but...
l am happy with my purchase except that one case was broken and the DVD does not hold in there and it rattles; really annoying and l don't think that will be good for the disc.
Buyer Rating: 
-
* Updated version ...
When l purchased these movies, l didn't realize they were the updated version. Well, they are, so if you like that, this is for you, if you want the strictly classic ones, this isn't them. l happen to like the updated version.
The Dave_
Buyer Rating: -
What's so great about the original versions anyway?
l am glad George Lucas added extra scenes to this trilogy and fixed some minor details in the films. What is so great about the originals? The newer versions look better so quit complaining you purists. Anywho-this is a great story with great actors and great(for the time) special effects. Everyone should see these movies at least once.
